Muscle vs. Fat: A Calorie Burning Comparison
There’s a popular belief that having more muscle means you’ll burn a ton of extra calories while at rest. While that’s not really true, the real value of building muscle goes far beyond that myth.
Let’s break it down and uncover the facts about how muscle and fat affect your metabolism—and why building lean muscle and staying strong is still one of the best things you can do for your health—no matter what your age.
Muscles Burn More Calories at Rest?
Some even say that every pound of muscle burns 50 calories a day at rest. Sounds amazing, right? Unfortunately, the reality isn’t quite that dramatic. While it’s true that muscle is more metabolically active than fat, the difference isn’t as huge as many people think. Let’s look at the numbers:
One pound of muscle burns about 6 calories per day at rest.
One pound of fat burns about 2 calories per day at rest.
So, if you gain 10 pounds of muscle, you’ll only burn an extra 60 calories daily, which is roughly equivalent to just over half an apple. Yes, muscle does burn slightly more calories, but it won’t magically torch hundreds of extra calories while you’re sitting on the couch.
Why Strength Training Rules
If muscle doesn’t burn that many extra calories at rest, you might wonder: is strength training even worth it? Absolutely. Here’s an overview of why:
It Burns Calories During and After Workouts
Strength training can create an “afterburn” effect, where your body continues to burn calories for up to 72 hours post-workout. High-intensity sessions are especially effective at boosting this afterburn.It Changes Your Body Composition
Building muscle helps you look leaner and more toned, even if the scale doesn’t change much. Muscle takes up less space than fat, so you’ll notice a difference in how your clothes fit.It Boosts Metabolism Over Time
While the calorie-burning difference per pound of muscle is small, having more muscle overall can add up. Plus, muscle helps you move more efficiently, which means you’ll burn more calories during everyday activities.It Protects Your Health as You Age
Strength training is about more than aesthetics—it’s about staying strong and independent as you get older. It helps prevent muscle loss, strengthens bones, and reduces your risk of conditions like osteoporosis, type 2 diabetes, and high blood pressure.
How Muscle Burns Calories
Where muscles really shine is during movement. Because it’s one of the most abundant tissues in the body, it can burn a substantial number of calories when put to work. During exercise, especially intense workouts like resistance training or cardio, your muscles demand a lot of energy. That's partly because big muscles tend to have more calorie-hungry fast-twitch fibers, specialized for lifting weights, rather than slow-twitch fibers built for endurance.
Generally speaking, a light strength workout can burn around 110 calories (depending on a person’s weight), while a 30-minute cardio workout, such as hiking, can burn around 185 calories.
After your strength workout though, there’s still some action going on. Think about a car, after a long road trip, taking some time to cool down. Your body works in a similar way. Once you’ve finished exercising and resumed your daily activities, your metabolism remains elevated, allowing you to burn more calories than you would at complete rest.
This is known as excess post-exercise oxygen consumption (EPOC), often referred to as “oxygen debt.” EPOC represents the extra oxygen your body requires to recover and restore itself to its baseline, balanced state, called homeostasis. This recovery phase allows the body to continue burning calories after exercising.
And if you continue to be active throughout the day after the cooldown period, your lean muscle will still burn more calories. This is due to Non-Exercise Activity Thermogenesis (NEAT), which is the energy you burn during everyday movements.
While these explanations may be a little nerdy, what it boils down to is that higher muscle mass moves a larger amount of metabolically active tissue, which burns more calories. This is why strength training and building muscle are so valuable.
Organs and Metabolism
While muscle and fat play a role in calorie burning, they’re not the biggest players. Your organs—like your brain, heart, kidneys, and liver—are responsible for most of your daily energy expenditure. These organs burn about 20 times more calories than resting muscle.
For example, your brain alone burns around 20% of your daily calories, even though it only accounts for 2% of your body weight. This highlights that metabolism is about more than just muscle and fat—it’s a complex system involving every part of your body.
Still, building lean muscle through strength training is one of the best things you can do for your health. It improves your body composition, boosts your metabolism during and after workouts, and helps you stay strong and independent as you age. Think about the bigger picture: using strength training as a powerful tool for overall health, longevity, and quality of life.
I'm grateful you're here! I want to make my articles available to everyone, which is why they're free. But if you find them helpful, please consider a small paid subscription. It helps cover the costs of running this site and allows me to continue independent, unbiased research and journalism. Thanks for your support!
If shy about commitments, feel free to leave a one-time (coffee) tip through a Ko-fi contribution! Your generosity is greatly appreciated!
© 2025 (C) Jorg Mardian; "StrongHealth" on Substack.com
Solid article !